Robert Pirsig on Freedom
From ‘Lila:’
“Of all the contributions America has made to the history of the world, the idea of freedom from a social hierarchy is has been the greatest…”
“And yes, although Jefferson called this doctrine of socially equality ’self evident,’ it is not at all self evident. Scientific evidence and the social evidence of history indicate the opposite is self-evident. There is no ’self-evidence’ in European history that all men are created equal. There’s no nation in Europe that doesn’t trace its history back to a time when it was ’self-evident’ that all men are created unequal.
Jean Jacques Rousseau, who is sometimes given credit for this doctrine, certainly didn’t get it from the history of Europe or Asia or Africa. He got it from the impact of the New World upon Europe and from contemplation of one particular kind of individual who lived in the New World, the person he called the ‘Noble Savage.’
The idea that ‘all men are created equal’ is a gift to the world from the American Indian. Europeans who settled here only transmitted it as a doctrine that they sometimes followed and sometimes did not. The real source was someone for whom social equality was no mere doctrine, who had equality built into his bones. To him it was inconceivable that the world could be any other way. For him there was no other way of life.”






September 29th, 2009 at 4:36 pm
Yes, it is the “greatest.” It is also the one that will end by its falling to tyranny. The idea is based essentially on a absence of principle. It is, in fact, the achilles heel of the US. In realiy, freedom, like every positive quality, is a reflection of a superior reality: the flight of a bird may be contrasted with a bird in a cage. For human beings to participate in this superior reality, conditions are required, and the ideal of a freedom from any hierarchy precisely serves to deny the existence of such conditions. But course, there are hierarchies that are legitimate and recognize true principles, and there are false and tyrannical hierarchies.